The captive ferrule fitting can be removed and reinstalled repeatedly- - - -once it squeezes down on the tubing, it doesn't have to be removed again. It just swages down and puts a slight groove in the tube. The simple fix for the broken tube is to put a short piece of 1/4" OD copper tubing over the break and solder it into place. It's a quick, permanent fix, and it will be much better than a piece of rubber tube.
Jerry