Very weird. as said. New rubber should make it tight. Is it possible, besides what Caso said , that you have rubber on wrong? I don't think I would elongate holes yet until re thinking and being sure all parts are correct side and right side up and so on. I have seen many doors not fit flush and have uneven gaps but not being able to have an in and out tight fit with new rubber and latch/catch , I have not seen. Just to throw it all out there...sometimes you get parts from the wrong era.
Right is right, even if everyone is against it, and wrong is wrong, even if everyone is for it. - William Penn
| 
