I would suggest using the brass one. CHECK YOUR NEW ONE AND MAKE SURE IS MADE OF 100% BRASS,AS MANY AFTERMARKETS ONES ARE AN ALLOY OF STELL AND OTHER MATERIALS WHICH WILL IN TIME RUIN YOUR INPUT SHAFT.100%BRASS ONES WILL NOT STICK TO MAGNENT. THANKS TO MANY AFTERMARKET VENDERS THAT JUST PLAIN SELLING CHINESE JUNK. Like in south Florida when building times was in peak.there was shortage of drywall for the contractors,so venders started having the Chinese making the drywall and sending them over, in time many people were starting getting sick in those homes that were made of the Chinese drywall, finally someone figure it out, the Chinese were making the drywall literally out garbage and slop and whatever they can find to make it. a lot of homes in south florida lost it value and where not livable, It is just to show what the Chinese marketers will do to make a buck.
