The fender emblems are from a '58. The '59s should look like a rocket instead of a jet plane. Very good chnace the fenders may have been swapped without the emblems switched over. The correct 3200 emblems are not being reproduced for any year, seems the 3100 versions are the only ones. even then, only the '55 and '57 versions, plus the '57 3124 (Cameo) have been repopped.
I would suggest hunting the salvage yards. You don't say where in Indiana you are, but if you can get to the Marion Co. Fairgrounds this September, there is a rather large swapmeet there every year. Might be able to find them there.
