$250 for a good rear fender is a great deal. If you really want a good one that does not need a lot of work plan to pay upwards of $500 or even more. I searched for over 5 years for a set of good steal rear fenders and ended up paying a ton to get them.
Good luck.
Last edited by cletis; 02/22/2009 6:37 PM. Reason: removed reference to deleted ebay link.