You're right Phil, I'll try to find a replacement switch before I open it up. I fiddled with it this evening for a few minutes and had a hard time getting the four-ways to shut off. Something must be floating around inside the switch.
Tiny linked to a thread in the VCCA forum, a guy buy the name of Hawkeye opened his switch up and included pics. I've attached some of those pics. Thanks Hawkeye!