Darcy,
The problem is the original (40-46) was a Beige hammered texture. The only hammered I can find is Hammerite and Rust-Oleum. I can not find anyone willing to even try to match the Beige color in a hammered texture.
Too bad J.C. did not get the formula

from his supplier before the paint co. shut its doors.
I guess I will have to go with the darker color he now sells.
Harold