until 56 all original temperature gauges were mechanical, which is what those that operate via a Bourdon [capillary] tube,
filled with ether, are called, an electric gauge in a 55.2 would be a replacement, or possibly end of the year production, although the earliest 56's also had mechanical gauges
maybe your electric sender isn't sensing properly because it doesn't fit the location as the original mechanical bulb did, I believe the location and hole size for the sender changed for the electric gauge, you may have an adapter there affecting it -
here's a mechanical gauge for saleBill