I think you have the wrong seal installed.I believe you should have the wick seal or also known as a rope seal.It looks like you have a neoprene seal that was used staring in 1959. rear main seals

Some others will chime in shortly,lets see what they have to say.

Tim

1951 3100 Chevrolet
1951 Chevrolet Suburban Carryall
Image
"A house is built with boards and beams. A home is built with love and dreams."
"Look deep before you leap !!!" / "Everything is Everything"
"If I say a mouse can pull a house, hitch him up"