Mine is a column shift,I've driven both and can honestly say that I could care less,my fathers truck was column and his work trucks were all floor shift 4 speed panel trucks.I would guess that it's what ever you get used to,I wouldn't change my truck to floor shift I see no advantage.I did notice that when I finished my truck it took a while to teach the kids the shift pattern on the column.It's hard to see the H from the side verses the H on the floor. I grew up on both and started driving when I was 12 or 13 so both feel natural and both ways are good arm rests when driving.
If you do convert a three speed on the column to floor shift get a repo floor trans panel so you can cut that up and keep all the column shift parts that way it's all there and be converted back.
Pete
Last edited by Pete52; 10/30/2011 11:56 PM.