Hi Jason, I installed them both facing the same way. Also be sure to check where the old seal was in contact with the shaft when all the way down. Sometimes there can be a wear spot on the shaft that will cause the new seal to leak. Usually emery cloth will buff that wear spot out.
Also, another set of hands would be nice putting the piston back in the cylinder, it's kind of a bear by yourself.
It's sure nice when fixed not to have it leaking all over the differential, so it's certainly worth the effort.
Good luck, hope to see some pics.
Paul.
