Hello MikeE, It basically depends on what Sabrina wants to achieve. Whether she wants to restore to original, or express a little creativity. I figured that she was seeking ideas to not only mask or repair a hack job, but to also solicit different possible options for something a little more unique.
I think that is safe to assume that the damage to the dash was done to accommodate some type of accessory in the first place. (Like a tach, gage or radio).
Beings the damage is already done, maybe this would be a good time to customize the dash to fit her individual needs. She could install a built in cup holder or a place to keep an extra clip for her assault rifle.
Just kidding, but the options are unlimited.