The only disadvantage to Welch type plugs is that they're only available in steel, which rusts out. I've been tinkering with an idea to make a set of forming dies so I can fabricate brass plugs of the same design, using an arbor press or a hammer and anvil. 3/32" brass flat stock is available, and it would just be a matter of getting the right dome shape formed to make it expand and seal properly.
Jerry