From what I could gather here Group 5.188 - Cover is the Master parts Catalog listing for these. See snapshots below for more details. Your metal ones were definitely original equipment.
Your call if you want to use the rubber ones you already have or if you want something period correct???
Hope this answers your questions.
Dan
~ Dan 1951 Chevy 3 window 3100 Follow this story in the DITY Gallery "My Grandpa Carl's Truck and How it Became Mine" 1966 Chevelle (Wife's Hot Rod) | 2013 Chevy Silverado (Current daily driver) US Army MSG Retired (1977-1998) | Com Fac Maint Lead Tech Retired (1998-2021)