You should be able to extend your spare carrier bar downward, assuming the bolts fastening it to the crossbars are long enough.
Or you could buy a new 6.50-16 tire
HERE. I got 5 of them for my truck at just under $100 each. Had to do a jump through a few hoops to get them to me in Alaska. They wanted $3000 to ship them to me directly, but offered free shipping to the lower 48.