I just checked my '51 and the only way you can see the white paint in the truck is from a severe angle, almost parallel to the dash, using a flashlight. It is covered by the insert with the gauge type lettering. The purpose is to reflect as much light as possible onto the gauge faces. My gauge cluster is original and looks slightly off white, more like ivory (like yours), but the above suggestions are excellent.
Kent

1937 Chevy 1/2 ton
1942 Chevy 1/2 ton
1947 Diamond T Model 509
1951 Chevy 1/2 ton
1950 Chevy COE Model 5700 ~ "Barney" ~ And more pix