I went "high tech" a few years ago and bought a well-used set of gasket punches from Ebay. With a little sharpening, they're good as new. A slab of hard maple or red oak is just the right hardness to get clean cuts without dulling the cutters excessively. The thin cardboard backing piece from a pad of scratch paper is about the right thickness for most gaskets like thermostats, fuel pumps, etc.
Jerry