Mine was the lighter blue although I did not compare it to the actual painted pieces. I kept remnants of the original headliner for comparison and my cross sills are still in original paint until ready for that part of the project.

On a side note, I believe you used the formula from the original scanned colors from my truck and you sent me paint gun flakes of the lighter color. It looked like a very good match. I was wondering if you used and liked the darker blue scan as well.