I'll try again tomorrow. I already installed the switch early this afternoon noon. Before I installed it I did a continuity check on the new switch in the same pairs as described and I got the same as before. It has to just be the way this switch is. I did a continuity check on the old switch and everything work how it was supposed to, 11 o'clock has continuity between battery and accessory, 12 o'clock had no continuity between any of the terminals, and 1 o'clock had continuity between all the terminals.
Guess I'll be looking into another switch down the road. This one will work and serve its purpose for now.
Thanks everyone
