Maybe this is why I've had a spare stomp starter lying around for so many years. Some day.........
I switched over my 6v rig to 12v some years ago. Starter rarely gives me an issue. Once in a while it will freely spin when I lightly stomp on it, but not very often. I should find the spare to see where the gear resides when extended as well as confirming the shaft diameter.
Craig
My '50 Chevy 3100 5 window, '62-235cu, 3:55 rear
My truck ....... Respect The Rust
If I'm not working on my truck, '65 m00stang or VW camper, I'm fishing with the wife or smoking Salmon.