klhansen,

I talk to the parts guy over at vapinc and he thinks the bushing puller might have been made incorrectly.
The O.D. of the finger hooks on my puller don't jive with the puller they were looking at.

O.D. of the finger hooks: (uncompressed)
My reading, 1 1/2"
There reading, 1 7/16

O.D. of the finger hooks: (compressed)
My reading, 1 7/16"
There reading, 1 5/16" Small
The I.D. of front bushing is, 1 5/16"

The gap between fingers:
My reading, 1/32" Big
There reading, between 1/16" to 1/8"

He thinks the gaps between fingers where made on the lathe.
Using the wrong width cutting wheel/tool.
He said' That they would send me out a new one.
I said' What do you want me to do with the one I have.
He said' Throw it in the garbage.
I said' OK

I'm keeping my Fingers Crossed, no pun intended.

Thanks for Your suggestions.
I'll let you know if it shows up at the door step.
Then I'll do a comparison.