Carl, were they made so the door is 1/4" bigger than the opening? Nosir, I don't think so! THAT was the issue. Nevermind the rubber, with it out and nothing keeping the door from closing, there was 1/4" before it would slide into place! If it were looks I was caring about, I wouldn't be warning him of the vast differences. You can SAY they are all compatible, but you would be wrong.
Cab being too small, (both) doors being too big, doesn't matter.. the poster needs to know to check them before purchase.