Only one guy cranked these fenders out & the tooling was produced in the orient 3 years ago. All the suppliers have the fenders from this one guy. No difference in quality between retailers [ only price ]. I have heard of 2 people now who have bought them & complained that the gauge thickness of them was like a " beer can " & resold them & went with restored original fenders.
On the other hand I have talked to guys who did not care about originality & liked them [ if you dont lean on them ].