I used this
http://tapes.berryplastics.com/SearchProductsDetails.aspx?ID=131I have done some research on sound dampening tapes. What I found was that most are made from foil and butyl rubber or asphalt. They can also be a combination of butyl and asphalt. Asphalt is less expensive, doesn't work as well, has a more narrow temperature window and gives of smelly fumes.
When you look below the surface and marketing fluff most of these tapes are products used in manufacturing so they are built to a spec and have a cost benefit trade off for the various types of materials used. They are then branded with the various trade names (Dynomat, fatmat, second skin, lizard skin, eastwood ect) and marketed to people like us.
My advise would be to look for a local "tape store". They specialize in adhesives for industrial applications. I don't know if I am lucky or what but I have three within a half hour of my house. Talk to them and explain you want low VOC foil tape with a high butyl content. They sell it in various thicknesses for different applications. I think Dynomat is 68mm.
What I did get 35mm and then double up in the higher heat higher noise areas. Ultimately it was about half the price of going with any of the second tier brands (non-dynomat).