Bruce,
You are only comparing apples and oranges unless you know specifics about what coverage you want and what conditions/requirements are imposed on your use of the vehicle. Also, as indicated above, your state/location is an important cost-factor.
Some coverage information would be:
Liability 100,000/300,000/100,000:
100,000 per person personal injury liability
300,000 per accident personal injury liability
100,000 per accident property damage liability
100,000 supplemental uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage (for people in my vehicle) in addition to NYS required PIP Personal Injury Protection
5,000 per person Medical Payments (for people in my vehicle)
Full collision and comprehensive ($0 deductible )
Road service and towing (flatbed tow service, lock-out assistance, jump start) - up to 3 per year ($50 per event - could be changed to $100 per event).
Cost: Around $200 for two antique vehicles per year (agreed replacement values of $10,000 and $15,000 - I provided pictures via email).
There are three household drivers (one high risk) in my family and three other fully insured "normal" vehicles.
Some conditions/requirements are:
1. You must have another fully insured vehicle.
2. Your antique vehicle cannot be significantly modified (mostly speed-type modifications are not allowed).
3. I think your antique vehicle must be stored in a garage.
4. Your antique vehicle cannot be used for driving to work (to your job/employment).
5. You cannot use the antique vehicle for income-producing activity.
6. The vehicle must over 25 years old.
7. You are allowed limited pleasure driving. It is a pleasure to drive my '54 pickup to carry things for me and for my friends.
Many insurance companies have websites where you can indicate the levels of coverage that you want and the cost of the policy is immediatelt calculated for you. The best sites also clearly state the conditions/requirements of their policies. You might want to check out
Hagerty Insurance for comparison with other "collector vehicle" policies.
I chose Hagerty because its website gave the clearest quotes and coverage information of all the companies I found listed in Hemmings. Also, I easily got a human being on the phone and they allow me to change coverage limits on-line. I am allowed to drive my trucks daily for pleasure purposes but I am not supposed to drive it everyday to work. (I could drive it to work every a few days a week).
Good luck,
Tim