Give them a call first, here's a clip from their "about us" page
...doing it right. Anybody can weld a wheel, all it takes is a welder. You can even do it out of your house. The trick is to make sure it's round when you're through and that it stays together after you put it on your vehicle. It helps when you're committed to do the kind of job you would want for your own car.
If they stand up for their work and name I expect they'll have a solution for you.
They have a new owner between now and when you had those made right?
Grigg