Maybe Jim Carter has a different antenna than the one now sold by Classic Parts? I bought mine several years ago - one from each vendor. The last one I got was from JC.
He sells two styles at significantly different prices.
http://www.1954advance-design.com/Photos/Reassembly/23_AntennaHood3.jpgI now recall that I had to send one set back to one of the vendors - it came with an incorrect combination of plastic cover, cast base, and bracket. I would not have guessed that something was wrong if I did not have another set that was correct. Maybe if you post photos, I can compare to the un-mounted set that I have.
Tim