I have not dealt with Jim Carter, so I can't comment on them. However, I have done a lot of business with LMC and Classic Parts. LMC has gotten my order wrong on more than one occasion and the last order I placed with them for an upholstery kit took a month to get here. LMC does do okay, and I have had mostly good experiences with them.
Classic Parts is my go-to company, though. I have never had a single problem with any order I have placed with them and their customer service is great. They also give a discount for Stovebolt members. And their free shipping on orders of $300 is handy too (excluding oversize items).
Just so you know, in the last 6 months I have ordered about $1,000 in parts from LMC and Classic and what I've written has been what I've experienced in this timeframe.
