I've only used the Eastwood Rust Converter and I like it. It's water based and seems to do what it's advertised to do and now it's available in aerosol which I have yet to try.

I've also used their Rust Encapsulator.

I'm very happy with those products.

Woody
Your Brother in Bolthood

My 1951 half-ton 'Ol Red

Save the VINTAGE DOOR ART! Please contribute photos.
Door Art Collection