I purchased a new after market for my driver's side door. It never seemed to work right, as stated, door wouldn't open or close tight. At about 6 months it broke and pieces fell out. I found NOS and no problems. The NOS was only about $30.00 more than repop.

1950 Chevy 3100
261, 4 speed
Purchased 1977

1964 Pontiac Lemans Convert