If I was being given one, either would be ok. If I was to buy, probably neither. It's hard to say, though. I didn't care for the '99-'06 Chevy/GMC fullsize when they first came out & now I drive an '02 Z/71 Xcab Silverado. Think sometimes it has to do with what you are exposed to, meaning that the more you see something, it tends to grow on ya.
