You have a tape measure on the driver side fender that reads 11 1/8" just where the tape wraps over the top of the headlight. What does the passenger side measure when placed at the same start location?

I think you have the correct fenders. One of them just got squashed and didn't get stretched back out to its original contours.

1950 Chevrolet 3100 (Ol' Roy)

1939 Packard Standard Eight Coupe (The Phantom) | 1956 Cadillac Coupe de Ville (The Bismarck) | 1964 Ford Galaxie 500 coupe |1966 Ford Mustang (Little Red) | 1969 Pontiac GTO (The Dishpit) I 1979 Ford F-100 | 1976 Ford F-150 (Big Red) | 1995 Ford F-150 (Newt)