As long as the overall length from the top of the valve with no tension to the thread is the same, either work well.

The original Carter plunger looked like a miniature golf tee, some of the aftermarket plungers are just a round shaft.

Either works.

Jon.

Good carburetion is fuelish hot air
The most expensive carburetor is the wrong one you attempt to modify.
If you truly believe "one size fits all," try walking a mile in your spouse's shoes!
The Carburetor Shop