I have a '59 235, it has the large canister filter that U-bolts to the exhaust manifold. Someone had put the wrong element in it so I went on a short wild goose chase.

The one that fits mine is a NAPA 1100 element. They actually had it in stock! If your's is like mine, you have to siphon the oil out of the canister, as there is no drain plug.
Hope that helps.
-kevin