Breaking two bolts in the same hole is one too many, without finding out what's causing the problem. Maybe there's an obstruction in the bottom of the hole that's allowing the bolt to bottom out, or something similar. I'd suggest installing a Heli-Coil in that thread, and making sure that the hole is deep enough to let the bolt squeeze the head gasket properly. The best fix would be to install ARP studs in all the holes,instead of using 70 year old bolts. That's what we did on 1,000+ HP tractor pull engines.
Jerry