I buy bunches of rods on Ebay, and so far I haven't been disappointed. I'm stockpiling Babbit rods, about 60 so far, to start converting them to insert bearings when I get the rest of my rod-boring fixtures set up.
I ran the rod reconditioning department of a big machine shop in Nashville for several years, and it was unusual to find a used rod that was not at least a little out of round. We tried to hold our reconditioning tolerances to +/- .0001".
Swapping the problem bearing to another rod is a good idea- - - -if the tight spot moves, you've got an out-of-spec bearing, not a rod problem. I've been known to mix and match individual bearing shells when I was looking for a specific oil clearance number on some of the race engines I've built.
Jerry