I still have to wonder if the pick up fenders are the same shape. Do the people who make the repro steel pickup fenders offer delivery fenders? They certainly would if the fenders were the same shape. So if they are not, I would say it is likely they are not the same shape.

But, a banged up pickup fender is worthless, so give it a try.

1948 Chevy Pickup
Chopped and sectioned
owned since 1974 when I was 15.